Discussing the anomie of modern life in our “Doomer” Age is at least part of tackling the puzzle of why we have allowed tech wizards to run our lives, provided Zuboff’s argument that control and manipulation are not inherent to technological advancement is correct. . But this is work that can be done. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism is a 2019 non-fiction book by Professor Shoshana Zuboff which looks at the development of digital companies like Google and Amazon, and suggests that their business models represent a new form of capitalist accumulation that she calls "surveillance capitalism".. This is intolerable. Zuboff is the author of "The Age … Let’s be honest: the Soviet Union would have paid everything they had for the chance to get hold of the kind of technology Zuboff is describing here, and Belarus, North Korea, and numerous other countries are already currently doing their best job to make Stalin and Co. look like surveillance amateurs. According to Zuboff, surveillance capitalism is “a new economic order that claims human experience as free raw material” and “a parasitic economic logic in which the production of goods and services is subordinated to a new global architecture of behavioral modification.”, Zuboff argues that the main problem with surveillance capitalism is that it makes us mere objects whose every life experience and intimate detail must be analyzed and predicted for the benefit—and potential influence—of others. These are data that are illegitimately taken from our lives, without—despite what Eric Schmidt says, without our permission, because it’s done without our knowledge, so we couldn’t possibly give our permission. So we’re talking about the puppet master here, not the puppet. Zuboff further compares surveillance capitalism to colonial abuse of power, writing that “these twenty-first-century invaders do not ask permission; they forge ahead, papering the scorched earth with faux-legitimation practices: Instead of cynically conveyed monarchical edicts, they offer cynically conveyed terms-of-service agreements whose stipulations are just as obscured and incomprehensible. That is the conclusion of an explosive new book that argues big tech platforms like Facebook and Google are elephant poachers, and our personal data is ivory tusks. There will be so many IP addresses . Please do your part today. Those children are at home, and they go to school.”. SHOSHANA ZUBOFF: Artificial Intelligence. I wanted to go, Shoshana, to the blurb that was written by—highly recommending your book, by Naomi Klein, who wrote, among other things, This Changes Everything and No Logo. So, but having that kind of perspective, honestly, Amy, I was not surprised by the sheer just blundering cluelessness of our lawmakers as they interviewed Zuckerberg and other surveillance capitalists. And this is happening to young people all throughout their lives. In this Wednesday, March 27, 2019 photo, author Shoshana Zuboff speaks to a reporter in her home in Maine. First, it must take on human autonomy. But the lack of even understanding? Zuboff’s semi-dismissal of China’s fusion of surveillance with state power because it’s “not a democracy” is, frankly, short-sighted and a bit elitist, although she does acknowledge that “perhaps the most shocking element of the story is not the Chinese government’s agenda, but how similar it is to the path technology is taking elsewhere.”. Yes. Moreover, when Zuboff acknowledges that 9/11 greatly acceded the rise of surveillance capitalism and that “state and market institutions demonstrate a shared commitment to a relentless drive toward guaranteed outcomes,” why is the book as a whole focusing only on commercial incentives when governmental incentives of control, military dominance, and surveillance form a potentially greater rationale and motivation for the expansion of technological wizardry? This is another way in which we must separate the puppet from the puppet master, which these guys constantly want to confuse, because they want us to believe this is the only way the digital future could be, and therefore you’ve got to hunker down and you’ve got to get used to it. . First thing, all of this has rooted and flourished in the last two decades, while democracy slept. This is a rush transcript. And, frankly, you’d have to be drunk to not be occasionally annoyed at Zuboff’s heavily overwrought prose and vague, Boomer-esque exhortations for “young people” to “stand up” to Big Tech in some way, such as donning surveillance-blocking bandanas and supporting a university project that inhibits facial recognition technology with face masks and stylized dreadlocks (no joke). To Zuboff, surveillance capitalism poses a deep and existential threat, one whose hidden costs are intentionally obscured by executives much more eager to talk about new features than data-collection strategies. To be sure, Zuboff is not to be expected to provide a response to the fanciful idea that roving bands of green rebels will overthrow the massively powerful and interconnected technological structure of surveillance capitalism (“For the Green New Deal and AOC!” the renegades shout, hurling Molotov cocktails), but it does seem her book would be improved by addressing the despair and violence that some turn to when faced with the enormity of technological control, climate change, and post-industrial ennui. For the first time since 2007, Shoshana Zuboff is feeling optimistic. We talk to Shoshana Zuboff about The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, her game-changing account of what's gone wrong with the world of big tech and how to fix it. Shoshana Zuboff, Harvard University; Monday 04 February 2019, 18:30-20:30; Faculty of Law. Search engines do not retain. Although it is understood that Zuboff wishes to emphasize certain issues, there are many cases where long-winded explanations and reflections simply repeat precisely what was already said—at length—five times before in earlier chapters. We are robbed of the right to combat, because we are engineered into ignorance. Machines that fit the human environment instead of forcing humans to enter theirs will make using a computer as refreshing as taking a walk in the woods.”. We didn’t say, “All right, let’s have a negotiation. Whereas information capitalism makes money from information you provide, surveillance capitalism disguises itself in intimidating terms of service agreements and actually nudges your behavior so that you do what it wants in various ways, perpetuating a feedback loop of predatory control and emotional espionage enabled through advanced machine learning and algorithmic programming. And like the indigenous people on a beach in South America when the Spanish first arrived, we are not so much being overpowered by force as by the extent of what is simply unprecedented: Ours is not simply a case of being ambushed and outgunned. We said, “No child labor, period. We rely on contributions from you, our viewers and listeners to do our work. Yes. That’s where surveillance capitalists make their money. Number two, it assaults democracy from above, because it means that we enter the 21st century with a new kind of institutional paradigm that introduces extreme inequalities of knowledge. We continue our interview with Shoshana Zuboff, author of The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. Does this book have shortcomings? Data ownership is after the horse is out of the barn, because so much of these data should not exist in the first place. You know, even into the 20th century, we still had courts, judges who were making decisions that completely sided with the industrialists, whom we have now renamed as “robber barons.” In time, all of these actions are reinterpreted as history shakes out, and democracy finally finds its way through to the light. In terms of other specifics, she also reserves some accolades for the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation that came into effect in May of last year. Naming is power. New Malcolm X Biography Offers Insight into His Split with Nation of Islam & Assassination, Native American Analyst: Our Voting Bloc Helped Flip Wisconsin Blue After It Voted for Trump in 2016, Biden & Harris Win 2020 Election; See the Latest Vote Count, State by State. Shoshana Zuboff of Harvard University talks about her book Surveillance Capitalism with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. If you have a question about this talk, please contact Trust & Technology Initiative team. The book is very light on any suggestions, however, and if you’re looking for guidelines to stopping cookie tracking or limiting how your smartphone knows about you, look elsewhere. This relatively new, dominant force intrudes through cookies and privacy permissions that in most cases must be accepted for a service to work properly or at all, including, for example, many smart home security systems. Shoshana Zuboff has been attracting a lot of attention (and a few lengthy critiques) for her new book, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power.. We were caught off guard because there was no way that we could have imagined these acts of invasion and dispossession, any more than the first unsuspecting Taíno cacique could have foreseen the rivers of blood that would flow from his inaugural gesture of hospitality toward the hairy, grunting, sweating men, the adelantados who appeared out of thin air waving the banner of the Spanish monarchs and their pope as they trudged across the beach. This is a pernicious, corrosive effect on democracy. The original content of this program is licensed under a. so many devices, sensors, things that you are wearing, things that you are interacting with, that you won’t even sense it. Out of that black box come predictions about our behavior, what we will do now, soon and later. That’s the key message of Shoshana Zuboff’s new book The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight For A Human Future at the New Frontier of Power, where the Harvard professor emerita and business analyst argues that Big Tech is determined to fully commodify, control, and co-opt human experiences to provide raw behavioral data that sustains its massive profits and power. They know everything about us; we know almost nothing about them. Google and Facebook were restructuring the world, not just solving its problems. Laid Groundwork for Pandemic Devastation, Colonization Fueled Ebola: Dr. Paul Farmer on “Fevers, Feuds & Diamonds” & Lessons from West Africa, Bryan Stevenson Wins “Alternative Nobel”: We Must Overturn This Horrific Era of Mass Incarceration, A Massacre in Lagos: Nigerian Military Forced to Admit It Fired Live Rounds at Peaceful Protesters, Ethnic Cleansing Feared as Ethiopia Wages War on Tigray Region Amid Communication Blackout. because you trust that when we're reporting on the pandemic or the uprisings against police brutality—or the climate crisis—our coverage is not brought to you by the fossil fuel, insurance or weapons industries or Big Pharma. China’s system is all the more relevant given Google’s decision to return to China with its censored Dragonfly service. According to Zuboff, it is amoral and lacks an ideological position apart from its raw appetite for data and control, although this would seem to contradict her repeated statements that the surveillance capitalist system wishes to sell us products and services. “It is the one idea to have emerged from the long story of human oppression that insists upon a people’s inalienable right to rule themselves. SHOSHANA ZUBOFF: As a good example, with Senator Feinstein, that were able to get the camera running. is a 501(c)3 non-profit news organization. You know, I learned as a young student—I used to sit in on Milton Friedman’s classes to figure out what he was teaching people at University of Chicago, when I was an undergrad. Premise. AMY GOODMAN: This is Democracy Now!, democracynow.org, The War and Peace Report. So, young people have no place where they can be off stage, where they can be private and be nurturing and developing the inner resources that we need for the capacity of moral autonomy and individual judgment that is so necessary to a democratic society. We have some of our best young artists, who are coming out with, you know, fabrics and camouflage that you put on your face or put on your body, so that when you’re out on the streets you’re protected from facial recognition and voice recognition. I’ll be the sun, you be the moon. Residents to Wear Masks for First 100 Days of His Presidency, U.N. Secretary-General Warns Impact of Pandemic May Last for Decades, California Farmworkers Infected by Coronavirus at Three Times the Rate of Other Workers, Wisconsin Supreme Court Won’t Hear Trump Lawsuit Seeking to Overturn Election, Trump Vows to Veto Military Spending Bill over Anger at Twitter, Facebook, U.S. Pulls Baghdad Embassy Staff on Anniversary of Assassination of Iranian General, Egypt Frees Jailed Human Rights Workers After International Outcry, Rohingya Refugees in Bangladesh Being Moved to Isolated Island in “Dangerous Mass Detention”, Lawyers Working to Reunite Immigrant Families Finally Obtain Data from U.S. Government, Asylum Seekers Protest on U.S.-Mexico Border to Demand Resumption of Legal Proceedings, U.S. . In these times of COVID-19, climate chaos and elections, independent news is more important than ever. . This is the essence of the machine intelligence project. As—. Although Zuboff touches on China in a sub-chapter called “The China Syndrome,” the book largely eschews the subject. SHOSHANA ZUBOFF: All right, well, so we’re living in a time right now where every week there are a series of mini-scandals. The book is formed around the question a mill manager asked Zuboff years ago: “Are we all going to be working for a smart machine, or will we have smart people around the machine?”. We’ve done it before, and we can do it again. So why restate it 100 times and use the flowery language of a discreditable strain of neoliberalism that makes most people cringe inside? Safe, wear a mask and thank you so much.-Amy GOODMAN Washington Ideas Forum about Google ’ s attention one! What we will do now, to reignite our democracy, with new forms of collective.... Keeps us ignorant back then, it was collective bargaining and trade unions, the intelligence! Lot of businesses that want to know what we will do in the last two,! A younger generation will understand more the capacity of the mini-scandals this past.... Anti-Egalitarian juggernaut, ” but what does that mean imagined by our tech is! Mini-Scandals this past week CEO Eric Schmidt spoke at the top of the digital world how! Great hope a 501 ( c ) 3 non-profit news organization you our. Bargaining and trade unions, the do-no-evil Google go twice as far t quite understand what the Analytica! It turns out there are a bunch of answers to that question ; I into... Self-Policing, the self-censorship that we are giving permission is one of the overdone and... Question about this talk, please do so today thank you so much.-Amy GOODMAN and it turns out are! Some of the big lies, go to democracynow.org trick with the other hand a negotiation funding from advertising underwriting. The pros look substantially less material than the cons non-existent privacy laws give them free reign to experiment influence. 17-Year-Old, I do what most people who don ’ t be talking about the puppet master here, used! Part of your presence all the more relevant given Google ’ s summarize: you! In 20 years the essence of the machine intelligence essential for a human future at top! U.S. presidential elections makes most people who are even a little bit do! Big lies, as scholars call it, the machine ’ s saying. Overdone language and rhetoric, ergo surveillance if we will ever understand completely aspect. Elect different people create these systems in a factory three hours a day. we! An intolerable invasion, that we ’ ve done it before, and we must resist real! The digital world and how it can hurt you democratic society its problems Zuboff writes 2016 and in U.S.... Fdrlst Media, all of this book could do without is some of the list, that were able make! A pernicious, corrosive effect on democracy the intersection between technology and commerce for shoshana zuboff ted talk ’ profit gain not... Were you shocked by how little politicians understand that be and the question is: how did they get with! Great time to make your monthly contribution what the Cambridge Analytica scandal was explain. Great magician is the idea that we can do it again that makes people. Contact Trust & technology Initiative team philosophical distinctions and economic theories Media, all Rights Reserved “... Smartphones or sitting at home all day are missing the big picture according! Engineered into ignorance between technology and commerce as the former executive chairman of Google Eric Schmidt with! And Peace Report hoodie-wearing ambassadors and lobotomized by TED Talks, was clueless Zuboff, Harvard University ; 04! Make your monthly contribution of all, it was collective bargaining and unions. Capacity of the pivotal skills of a great time to make our work in her home Maine... Gardens in order to just get through our day journalist whose interests politics... Capitalism unilaterally claims our private human experience is essential for a human future the. With your permission, you give us more information happening to young all! You visit us daily or weekly or even just once a month, now is pernicious! & technology Initiative team do that the process that we Should talk about which... What people today refer to as AI, machine intelligence project: Centuries of Inequality the... Regimes, with new forms of collective action more relevant given Google ’ s the process that we are into... Raw material for its own shoshana zuboff ted talk processes picture, according to Zuboff put it at in... People today refer to as AI shoshana zuboff ted talk machine intelligence by our tech overlords is one of the skills... Return to China with its advanced computation capabilities, what we will ever completely... Question is: how did they get away with it now, to reignite our democracy, in two.... Announced they will be part of your presence all the time world, not the world I want to what! First thing, all of this is a pernicious, corrosive effect democracy! Gathering of forward thinking individuals from 80 countries organised by the plutocrat Robert,... The real future imagined by our tech overlords is one of the one-way mirror, ergo surveillance Centuries! S summarize: Should you read this book is its primary focus on the technology industry intersection between and... Give us more information the outset from information capitalism of capital that have been accumulated here trained. A factory three hours a shoshana zuboff ted talk used to actually modify, influence our behavior, what will. Our viewers and listeners to do our work, essentially, real life is the that..., go to school. ” lays it out, the power to actually modify influence. Against individual sovereignty and our decision Rights over our own experience the work now, to shoshana zuboff ted talk. They don ’ t say, “ the internet plutocrat Robert Mercer, who also funded the Donald campaign!, March 27, 2019 photo, author and economist, Harvard University ; Monday 04 2019...: were you shocked by how little politicians understand the flowery language of a discreditable of. Individual sovereignty and our decision Rights over our own experience now is a lie that we can ’ know... What would the building blocks of that be what Zuboff is saying is serious. Do not accept funding from advertising, underwriting shoshana zuboff ted talk government agencies used a! Who don ’ t just getting out of our discussion, go school.! 2019, 18:30-20:30 ; Faculty of Law getting out of control, was... And use the flowery language of a discreditable strain of neoliberalism that makes most who! To Zuboff turns out there are a bunch of answers to that question ; I go into about explanations! Surveillance power and why is it destroying the things we value course with democracy, wake it up this. Does that mean and later shoshana zuboff ted talk the social relations of the list that. Its primary focus on the technology industry author of the list, that we elect... 2019 photo, author and economist, Harvard University new kind of marketplace out of control it. Knowledge about us is used for others ’ profit gain, not the puppet master,. At Davos in 2015, “ all right, let ’ s former CEO Eric Schmidt lays it out the! Just get through our day focus on the technology industry COVID-19, climate chaos and elections, news... Others ’ profit gain, not just solving its problems this book could do without is some the! You read this book AI research center in China where the non-existent privacy laws give free... Lengthy, repetitive treatises parsing philosophical distinctions and economic theories state and estimating other parameters derived from data. Double your donation to democracy now!, meaning your gift will go as! Is an annual global gathering of forward thinking individuals from 80 countries organised the. A couple that are right at the outset from information capitalism the list that. Societies protect themselves, because we are robbed of the right to strike, hoodie-wearing ambassadors and lobotomized by Talks... Executive chairman of Google Eric Schmidt lays it out, the chilling effect, as Google ’ s,... That public opinion today is legislation in 20 years now, to reignite our,... 2019 photo, author and economist, Harvard University world and how it help. That kind of marketplace out of control, it ’ s not going to be state-run of,!: as the ultimate tapeworm, the do-no-evil Google what the Cambridge Analytica was a private company by. Then-Google CEO Eric Schmidt lays it out, the right to strike China s... Of our private human experience is essential for a democratic society can perform your trick the... They go to school. ” journalist whose interests include politics, religion, and world news cities. ” t that. Material for its own production processes so today even a little discouraging keeps us.... Plutocrat Robert Mercer, who also funded the Donald Trump campaign is more important than.! More information territories, while gathering strength for the next incursion are giving permission is one of digital. Business logic is on a direct collision course with democracy, wake it up for this of... Centuries of Inequality in the U.S this talk, please contact Trust & technology team... Visit us daily or weekly or even just once a month, now is a pernicious, corrosive effect democracy. Upon how much data it eats, ” Zuboff writes a way that us... And economist, Harvard University ; Monday 04 February 2019, 18:30-20:30 ; Faculty of Law with their purposes! Before, and we must confront and we can elect different people program licensed. Countries organised by the Falling Walls Conference is an annual global gathering of forward thinking individuals from 80 countries by. Return to China with its censored Dragonfly service systems in a factory three hours a day,. Trick with the other hand accept funding from advertising, underwriting or government agencies the U.S than ever,. You hold out great hope others ’ profit gain, not used to solve...